r/TwoXChromosomes Jul 21 '21

Replace men with woman in a gory action film and suddenly its too feminist to watch?

I watched Gunpowder Milkshake last night and mentioned it this morning to my male coworkers during chit chat before work.

The only other guy who had seen the movie was a 20-something and he responded by saying he turned it off after 15 minutes bc it was hardcore feminist. My boss immediately asked, "what's wrong with feminism?" At the same time I looked at him and asked, "but it's just woman perfectly playing parts commonly played by men. How is that hardcore feminist?"

He looked a little surprised and shrugged his shoulders but didn't have anything to say. I've been thinking about it all morning. I liked the movie well enough (gory action isn't one of my favorites but I wanted to support the female centered crew) and while I was watching I got the distinct impression the movie is a cookie cutter action film that was written just like all the rest but when all was said and done they replaced all the juicy parts normally reserved for men with woman. Nothing special. Nothing new. Except it starred badass woman wielding guns, knives and tomahawks.

I figure we have such stringent expectations and perceptions of woman that when they break out of those molds and find purchase in a 'mans' space people get a funny taste in their mouth. Some people get angry, some bewildered and some secretly cheer. Very few are openly supportive. But what do I know I'm just a woman working as an industrial electrician. 👷‍♀️

Edit: Thank you for the awards kind strangers. I did not expect this to blow the fudge up but I'm pleased to have started a discussion. Hollywood pay attention and stop cheaping out!!

Okay so men perving this post need to get a life. If you're not putting words in my mouth you're insulting 50% of the world's population by breathing.

To all the commenters wow. I'm trying to get through all the responses but damn...

14k Upvotes

4k

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

It works with books too. I once gave an audiobook copy of On Basilisk Station to a male friend, and he said he stopped it because the over the top feminism was just too much.

For the unaware: On Basilisk Station is the first book in a series that's homage to CS Forrester's Horatio Hornblower books, and is no more socially progressive than the original, for its time. It does however cast women in many central and powerful roles, including the central protagonist. What it doesn't have is any kind of feminist approach to conflict or politics.

But it's too feminist for even a liberal American male.

978

u/SolidStateStarDust Jul 21 '21

I mean I guess we all probably know that women authors oftentimes abbreviated their names or took pen names so that the population wouldn't be able to discriminate between their work and a males work...

226

u/OraDr8 Jul 21 '21

In Australia we have a literary award called the Miles Franklin award. So many people have heard of the award but have no idea Miles Franklin was a woman, full name Stella Maria Sarah Miles Franklin. She dropped the feminine names to get published.

258

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

It's an ancilliary plot point in one of my favorite Star Trek episodes, Beyond the Stars (DS9).

344

u/PrivateIsotope Jul 21 '21

It's an ancillary plot because the character in Beyond the Stars is based on DC Fontana, a female writer who wrote a lot of episodes of the Original Series and was very influential to Star Trek in general.

98

u/CookiePush Jul 21 '21

These are the details I find most enchanting at 1am, thanks!

43

u/PrivateIsotope Jul 21 '21

No problem! As I remember, she wrote some Trek books too!

32

u/MrVeazey Jul 22 '21

Dorothy Fontana was a huge part of creating the Star Trek we know and love. That's an irrefutable statement, regardless of whether or not you say "feminist" like an insult.

→ More replies

16

u/AndrewJS2804 Jul 22 '21

And she took on the pen name D C because she was facing discrimination. It's sad that today after all her noteworthy contributions to the life and soul of the franchise every single aspect of the newer installments involving women are decried by a significant portion of the supposed fandom.

20

u/AlanFromRochester Jul 22 '21

Also for women in early Trek - Lucille Ball insisted her production company take on the original series Betty Jo "Bjo" Trimble was one of the prominent early Trekkies Uhura was groundbreaking as a nonstereotypical black female role. Nichelle Nichols is fond of telling the story of how MLK personally begged her not to quit. Whoopi Goldberg (later Guinan on Next Gen) said "I just saw a black lady on TV and she ain't no maid!"

In general while the anti PC accuse new Trek of being too preachy old Trek also laid it on thick at times.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

66

u/zombie_snuffleupagus Jul 21 '21

Wasn't James Tiptree called something like "clearly a male writer" by Robert Silverberg, who waxed poetic about the masculinity of "his" work?

Then shrugged when Tiptree turned out to be a woman.

Great short stories like "Love is the Plan, the Plan is Death", and one literally titled "The Women Men Don't See".

I feel I should mention her real name was Alice Sheldon, one of our best SF short story authors ever.

EDIT to add: that was the 70s, but I feel like JK Rowling understood too.

→ More replies
→ More replies

1k

u/Forward__Momentum Jul 21 '21

Jesus Christ. If On Basilisk Station of all things is too feminist for him, he'd probably explode or melt into a puddle if he read Bujold or Wells.

409

u/SonofFingol Jul 21 '21

I'm over here that thinking, "Man I'd love to read more books centered around strong woman roles!" I get tired of the usual man protagonist.

135

u/Amiiboid Jul 21 '21

Can I offer a plug for the work of Nicola Griffith here?

92

u/captainkrug Jul 21 '21

It's older stuff and I had to google to get remember the info properly, but the Serrano trilogy from Elizabeth Moon was a surprisingly good read. I borrowed them from my sister's collection when I was 19, had no expectations and was pleasantly entertained

56

u/Willuknight Jul 21 '21

Elizabeth Moon is amazing. Also reccomend Lois Bujold.

25

u/freyport Jul 21 '21

I [m] am a big fan of Elizabeth Moon's books. I think I've read almost everything she's written.

I'm personally just as happy to read a book with a female protagonist as a male one, regardless of the genre.

I'll have to check out Bujold -- always looking for new things to read.

32

u/Willuknight Jul 21 '21

You should also check out Wen Spencer, she's more fantasy than Sci-Fi. My favorite book of hers is "A Brother's Price" which is set in a Matriarchal world where men are sold and traded as breeding stock and is my partner's and mine's favorite. It's a very tongue in and cheek role reversal as well as having a solid story, though a little bit predictable at times.

→ More replies
→ More replies

11

u/PrivateIsotope Jul 21 '21

I loved the Vatta's War books by Elizabeth Moon.

→ More replies
→ More replies

52

u/epsdelta74 Jul 21 '21

'Matter' by Iain M. Banks. One of the protagonists is a female Culture agent in the Special Circumstances division (think sci fi CIA).

Honestly any of the Culture novels. Banks wrote them to be on the fringes of a very egalitarian post-scarcity society. Fantastically optimistic for the future of humanity... in general.

Yes, women can and do kick ass. But it's much more than that.

24

u/Fraerie Basically Eleanor Shellstrop Jul 21 '21

One of the key aspects of the Culture universe is that people are near immortal and can change gender (it takes time, not instant), virtually at will and tend to do so multiple times over their life span to have different life experiences.

14

u/majj27 Jul 21 '21

Plus the ship names are HILARIOUS.

13

u/dansedemorte Jul 21 '21

Ian was taken from the world too soon.

→ More replies

47

u/farmerchic Jul 21 '21

If you like fantasy it is hard to go wrong with By the Sword from Mercedes Lackey. I love a lot of her stuff, but that one is my fav.

14

u/blackwylf Jul 21 '21

I think that was my first Mercedes Lackey book growing up and it remains one of my favorites. She doesn't shy away from strong female characters!

→ More replies
→ More replies

118

u/pm_me_wutang_memes Jul 21 '21

May I recommend Leviathan Wakes? It's the first novel that sparked the tv series "The Expanse" and it's so good.

The central protagonist is a man, but the representation in that book is ace, and they don't applaud themselves for normalizing queer/Black/brown/women in vital roles within the series.

It's a pretty evenly weighted series of novels in regards to the ratio of men to women, and the ladies in that book are so complex and regularly subvert expectations. The moral compasses of all these characters evolve really meaningfully across the novels, and it's a series I'll reread many times over.

72

u/achairmadeoflemons Jul 21 '21

James is also sort of more often an audience camera then he is a character. Naomi, Chrisjen, and Bobby all are more interesting characters with generally more agency depending on the moment. Fun books!

13

u/surloc_dalnor Jul 22 '21

James is there mainly to do stupid things to move the plot forward.

12

u/achairmadeoflemons Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21

Yeah, or like, other people move the plot forward and James makes everything fucky and other people have to fix it.

I like James as a character quite a lot, he's flawed and idealistic but not unwilling to compromise or consider alternative ideas, He's quite a bit less smart than some of the other folks, but isn't stupid and absolutely comes off as a good leader.

Ugh, great series imo. I really enjoy how the books just let people be friends and trust each other.

→ More replies

9

u/HeThatMangles Jul 22 '21

“Don’t go sticking your dick in it James. It’s fucked enough already”

→ More replies
→ More replies

10

u/VexillaVexme Jul 22 '21

I've made the same argument with Holden. He's more of a plot device or a world-state than a real character (most of the time).

Chrisjen is probably my "favorite" of the three, but it's a slim lead. I think she's got the best character growth over the arc of the books.

10

u/achairmadeoflemons Jul 22 '21

Honestly, she's my favorite cause I love the smart older lady+potty mouth thing. Also, a lot of the sci-fi I have been reading recently (not like currently being written, just the time I'm reading it at) has this 'pro-military, government is stupid' sort of thing and I love the idea of smart public servants.

But like, there are just a ton of very charming characters in the series and I have a hard time thinking of someone who's motivations don't make sense. It feels frustrating and real.

→ More replies
→ More replies

11

u/lborgia Jul 21 '21

Seconded for The Expanse series! Just finished reading them all and dying for the finale!

→ More replies
→ More replies

22

u/MacScotchy Jul 21 '21

Just about anything by N. K. Jemisin.

→ More replies

19

u/LafayetteBeerLeague Jul 21 '21

Same! I was like oh shit! I should be adding this to the list!

13

u/massnerd Jul 21 '21

Alastair Reynolds if you like sci fi

→ More replies
→ More replies

75

u/humanistbeing Jul 21 '21

I so rarely see anyone suggest Bujold me. Gives me warm fuzzies. What Wells are you referring to?

87

u/Forward__Momentum Jul 21 '21

I'm an unapologetic Bujold fanboy - read every novel she's ever written and most of the short stories.

Martha Wells! I strongly recommend both her The Murderbot Diaries (it's a Hugo Award Winner, don't let the title scare you off) and her Books of the Raksura. Both of those series have good social commentary on gender roles (though it's less explicit in the Raksura books) and are independently really fun adventure stories with a lot of heart.

10

u/fushigidesune Jul 21 '21

Oh I might have to look at more of her work. I enjoyed the Vorkosigan series well enough. And I'll check out Wells while I'm at it.

17

u/Forward__Momentum Jul 21 '21

For Bujold, outside of the Vorkosigan books, here are some signposts you might find useful.

The Sharing Knife: These are the romance novels that convinced me that I like some romance novels. I liked Komarr and A Civil Campaign, because they weren't about contrived relationship problems, but about people who act like adults trying to make things work in tough situations. The Sharing Knife books are a lot of that, with some racial politics and demon slaying to keep you interested. Trigger warning emotional abuse.

The Curse of Chalion: The series that starts here is the most Vorkosigan-like of her non-Vorkosigan work. Atypical fantasy protagonists square off against problems personal and political. That said, there's a lot more explicit philosophy and spirituality here that I think is really unique. Bujold does suffering hero really well and does it here too.

Penric & Desdemona: These are set in the same universe as The Curse of Chalion and its sequels, but have a very different feel. Series of short stories about a man and the twelve dead women in his head. Spirituality is a big part of these too, but the tone is a lot lighter. Good for quarantines, struggles late into the night, and other times when you need something filling and good for the soul.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

17

u/blahdee-blah Jul 21 '21

Martha Wells, I expect.

→ More replies
→ More replies

22

u/Lovat69 Jul 21 '21

Martha Wells, assuming that's who you meant and not H.G., is one of my favorite authors. I've been reading her stuff since the Fall of Ill-Rien or however that's spelled.

Bujold is also very good.

→ More replies

98

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

I was honestly surprised. The guy is more or less "woke" on racial issues and at the far left edge of socially acceptable American politics.

143

u/DuckyDoodleDandy Jul 21 '21

Wow. That book was given to me by extremely conservative friends because we all like sci-fi.

But then, I just remembered that the parents met in the Army & the mom had been an officer while the dad was regular enlisted, so maybe the idea of a capable female didn’t sound so weird to them.

SMDH. Your friend needs to pull his head out of his ass.

58

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

He doesn't even think about voting Republican, so I have bigger pedagogical fish to fry these days.

→ More replies

72

u/Milkhemet_Melekh Jul 21 '21

These sorts of things happen more often than people realize. Being 'woke' isn't a substitute for actual understanding, and too often is an excuse to write off one's own biases. It might not even be a conscious thing, just an extension of the implicit biases and/or viewpoint of privilege one group tends toward.

18

u/mmmmpisghetti Jul 21 '21

Being 'woke' isn't a substitute for actual understanding, and too often is an excuse to write off one's own biases.

Wow. Yeah this right here strikes a chord.

84

u/yildizli_gece Jul 21 '21 edited Jul 21 '21

I have found that being liberal on race issues doesn't translate to being liberal on feminism or even understanding feminism.

It's why you'll see "jokes" that involve race or religion shut down as offensive but replace the scenario with a stereotype about women and suddenly there's a debate as to whether it's "really offensive" or that it's "just a joke".

It's also why there were SO many "progressive" Bernie supporters who nonetheless attacked Warren with blatantly misogynistic shit with that "snake" nonsense, and they could NOT understand how it was misogynistic to call her that (eye roll)...

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

93

u/moratnz Jul 21 '21

Wow. There are plenty of reasons to criticise the Honor Harrington series. Excessive feminism isn't one of them.

→ More replies

29

u/CaIamitea Jul 21 '21

Elizabeth Moon goes for strong female leads in military settings, and her sci-fi has a very militaristic nautical feel to them.

→ More replies

152

u/Increase-Null Jul 21 '21

Offer up Ancillary Justice by Ann Leckie next. (It’s a rather good series.)

See how he responds to the gender of all the characters being completely unclear/absent.

59

u/TheSasquatch9053 Jul 21 '21

Great book. It seems like such an obvious thing missing in scifi... Somehow re-growing limbs, brain transplants, and all kind of cybernetic appendages are going to be common but somehow everyone is going to maintain clearly discernable easily guessed genders?

60

u/Sisinator Jul 21 '21

Back in 1969, Ursula K. Le Guin published Left Hand of Darkness.

I just wrote up a brief description of the story, but I wasn't sure how spoilery it would be considered. Anyway I highly recommend it, imo it's no less relevant today than it was 50 years ago. A planet with no gender roles.

→ More replies
→ More replies

34

u/PrivateIsotope Jul 21 '21

Loved that one. It was very weird hearing every character being referred to as she by default. As a black man, it was also odd to me that everyone had brown skin.

→ More replies

57

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

I was thinking I'd give him Dawn by Octavia Butler.

50

u/Listentotheadviceman Jul 21 '21

Funny enough I just gave my “liberal who always argues conservative points for some reason” friend the very same book. I could go on and on and on about OEB, she was so damn good.

19

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

It's a good one for hidebound liberals who want to be woke but who claim to not understand gender issues, I think.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

61

u/Spank86 Jul 21 '21

It's a great series. I dont find anything "feminist"in it

Except in the sense that it portrays strong realistic women.

I fould understand if it showed every guy as an asshole and every woman as unnaturally amazing at everything, but it doesn't, nor does it try to. It just establishes good characters some of whom haopen to be female.

55

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

There are a number of male characters* portrayed positively in OBS, and one who is a socially privileged rapist and another who is a nefarious spy (Summervale).

There are a number of female characters portrayed well in OBS, and one (Hemphill) portrayed as a narcissistic impediment to the well being of the Navy, and another who is incompetent, disinterested and lazy (Suchon).

All in all, it seems like a pretty fair balance.

*McKeon, Venzilos, Tremaine, Harkness, Reynaud, Montoya, for starters

→ More replies
→ More replies

21

u/Monarc73 Jul 21 '21

I (40sM) have read the whole series, and actually found it to be very politically conservative.

→ More replies

152

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21 edited Jul 21 '21

Can't be very liberal if he's anti-feminist - probably just liberal when it suits him

Edit: Sorry, I'm from the UK and Liberal means something different here!

25

u/wolscott Jul 21 '21

I mean, the more liberal political party in the US still isn't really very feminist.

147

u/BootsySubwayAlien Jul 21 '21

There are tons of otherwise liberal men with mostly unexamined sexist biases. They are infuriating.

102

u/Auld_Folks_at_Home Jul 21 '21

"Brogressives"

(not mine)

→ More replies

44

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21

Well, when he was trying to get me to vote for Bernie , he seemed pretty liberal in the way Americans tend to measure the term. (welfare state liberalism)

And Liberalism in the broader theoretical sense seeks an agreeable consensus between existing power structures (conservatives) and those who would change them (working class representation, aka liberals). One can easily endorse that system while being extremely anti-feminist.

If he were a socialist and said such nonsense I'd have been flabbergasted, not merely shocked.

→ More replies
→ More replies

14

u/lutiana Jul 21 '21

Completely unrelated to the topic at hand, would you say that the story is ok for an 11 year old?

I am looking for a new audio book to listen to with my daughter on our commute to school each morning.

47

u/brettorlob Jul 21 '21 edited Jul 21 '21

It would not be appropriate until you've had a serious discussion about sexual assault. It's a central theme in one of the major character conflicts in the book (and early series).

Edit: there is another series by the same author set in the same universe that is intended for children your daughter's age. The first of those is "A Beutiful Friendship."

12

u/bornconfuzed Jul 21 '21

Second the recommendation of A Beautiful Friendship. The original Honor Harrington series would probably be a bit much for an 11 year old.

→ More replies

31

u/SilverDarner Jul 21 '21

More fantasy than SF, but it's hard to go wrong with Terry Pratchett or Neil Gaiman's YA stuff.
Diana Wynne Jones' books are magical and weird. Howl's Moving Castle, for instance, is great.

Seanan McGuire's YA series is enjoyable to me and my kid loved it, but some of the frankness might be awkward to listen to with your mom. While the Wayward Children (kids who go through a door to some sort of fantasy realm, come back and fail to fit in in the real world) don't veer off into anything too steamy beyond kissing and some implied canoodling, the teenage protagonists often fall well into the LGBTQ+ spectrum and work through some fairly difficult subjects. In addition to the general gay/straight kids there is an asexual (often overlooked) and some trans kids.

→ More replies

11

u/Scorpionvenom1 Jul 21 '21

I’m actually reading the series again. One of my all time favorites!

→ More replies

9

u/Peregrinebullet Jul 21 '21

I fucking LOVE that series, I was going to name my second child Eleanor Honor. But second child turned out to be male, so he got to be named Alastair instead (who is one of the secondary characters and a good friend of the protagonist after they get over their initial issues)

→ More replies

24

u/VoxVocisCausa Jul 21 '21

Lol. I almost put On Basilisk Station down because when we first meet Honour Weber has her wondering if she's pretty enough.

8

u/Peregrinebullet Jul 21 '21

I dunno, I think they do explore that enough later, both in the "prolong makes everyone awkward for a long time" sense and "what DO you do when you have an absolute knockout for a mom and she's basically your physical opposite?" sense

→ More replies
→ More replies

467

u/DConstructed Jul 21 '21

I understand that a lot of people want to watch films or read books with protagonists that remind them of themselves.

But just because the heroes don't look exactly like you does not make a film a political statement about gender or race.

163

u/GirlisNo1 Jul 21 '21

I’ve always loved adventure and war films and 99.99% of those feature men in the main roles and barely any women. I didn’t find them any less inspiring growing up as a young girl (though as an adult I do wish we got more women’s stories in these genres).

So I always find it puzzling that men can’t do the same…especially since they’re always trying to convince us they’re not sexist.

107

u/TheBreathofFiveSouls Jul 21 '21

These are the same guys that say representation in media isn't important. They're represented all the time so have zero idea what they're talking about lol

61

u/seffend Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21

So I always find it puzzling that men can’t do the same…especially since they’re always trying to convince us they’re not sexist.

I think that sexism is so ingrained in our society that most men wouldn't ever consider themselves to be sexist, even when they're doing or saying blatantly sexist things. It's similar to racism in that if it isn't overt, they don't see themselves falling into that category, but it can be so insidious. And they're seemingly incapable of recognizing it within themselves. A former boss of mine would never listen to ideas that I had, but a male coworker could make the same suggestion and he'd listen to him. I had worked there longer and had been in the business longer. It wasn't worth arguing over, so I would just have my male coworker make the suggestions instead. How fucking dumb is that, though? My former boss has a wife and a daughter that he loves very much and there's not a chance he'd consider himself sexist.

14

u/SlapTheBap Jul 22 '21

As a kid it really pissed me off. I was a voracious reader even as a kid and so few of the classics I read had good female leads or even side characters. It's part of why I fell in love with Dune in the fifth grade. Women were a huge part of the plot and had a lot of power. Finally, a power fantasy for women that wasn't a princess fantasy. Same reason I got so deep into Full Metal Alchemist when that hit American shores. They were islands in a never ending sea of weak women and strong men. There were others for sure but those two really got my attention at a young age.

→ More replies
→ More replies

2k

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21

[deleted]

1k

u/LounginLizard Jul 21 '21

I've heard that Ridley Scott and H.R. Geiger specifically tried to tap into peoples fear of rape when designing the aliens for Alien. The logic being that rape isn't something that men have to worry about on a day to day basis, so it would come across as extra unsettling to them and would maybe make them confront how violating it is. Can't say how well it worked, but it does explain the facehuggers laying eggs down peoples throats and the general abundance of sexual imagery in their design, although I think thats kinda a staple of Geigers work anyways.

183

u/RalfHorris Jul 21 '21

This is true, they very deliberately used sex as a horror device and the Alien has a distinctly feminine outline.

46

u/NervousPush8 Jul 21 '21

The facehugger has some distinct qualities as well.

→ More replies

166

u/Lotsofloveneeded Jul 21 '21

An effeminate body with a penis for a head. They werent very subtle.

→ More replies

43

u/Honigkuchenlives Jul 21 '21

Doesn't the alien rape one of the female crew members? Its definitely implied Imo.

38

u/Ahydell5966 Jul 21 '21

Yea - Lambert.

50

u/Honigkuchenlives Jul 21 '21

Never noticed when I was younger but its so clear now. How she is the only one that somehow lost her shoes and pants. Im glad Cameron didn't bring that part back.

→ More replies
→ More replies

12

u/RazekDPP Jul 22 '21

Lambert apparently had a bunch of different deaths scripted out, but was allegedly going to die of fright.

It was eventually decided that she would simply hide from the Xenomorph and die of fright, which makes complete sense given her fear level in the film. The problem was, the footage intended to be used to convey that didn't end up actually getting filmed. This left her death to be figured out in the editing stage, and that's why it happens offscreen. However, the sounds used effectively convey the horror of her end, proving that blood and gore isn't always needed.

https://screenrant.com/alien-movie-lambert-deaths-alternate-deleted-scenes/

→ More replies

61

u/UnicornOnTheJayneCob Jul 21 '21

Huh. that's interesting. I always thought of Alien as being much more akin to pregnancy and childbirth.

175

u/calilac Jul 21 '21

Well, pregnancy and childbirth are frequent results of rape

61

u/Racksmey Jul 22 '21

Also being forced to carry a child you don't want.

85

u/FiorinasFury Jul 22 '21

It impregnates a man by orally violating him, then because he isn't biologically predisposition to be able to give birth, the life inside him, not coincidentally shaped like a giant penis with teeth, erupts violently out of him. The giant penis monster then goes around forcefully penetrating the rest of the crew with its penis tongue.

It brings the concept of rape and the birth of a product of rape into the male space. Even if most people who watch it don't pick up on that subtext, the horror of it is often picked up subliminally.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

38

u/teamricearoni Jul 22 '21

I have this same theory about homophobia. Dudes can have some petty outrageous thoughts about women sometimes when it comes to sex. They know how they think about women and how they look and lust over women, so the thought of another man looking at them and thinking that way about them makes them uncomfortable.

The biggest homophobes are either usually horrible or creepy to women, and afraid of the same treatment from other men, or are gay themselves.

→ More replies
→ More replies

600

u/bambamkablam Jul 21 '21

Okay, I love ridiculous over the top action movies and I’m a feminist. Gunpowder Milkshake was already on my list of things I want to watch but it just got shuffled to the front. Men reacted the same way to Mad Max: Fury Road. My SO, who is generally pretty progressive, didn’t want to see it because he heard from his extremely toxic now former best friend, that it was just “man-bashing feminazi bull$hit” and Max was “barely even in it”. I sat him down and had him watch it with me and it’s now one of his favorite movies. He watches it all the time, and if someone comes to our house that hasn’t seen it, it’s usually what we end up watching. It’s embarrassing that it’s 2021 and the idea of a female character who isn’t half naked and always on the brink of a swoon will prevent men from seeing a movie that they would likely enjoy.

113

u/Honoris_Causa Jul 21 '21

I'm sorry what? Mad Max Fury Road is a feminist "man bashing feminazi bullshit" movie? Did we watch the same movie?

114

u/Lotsofloveneeded Jul 21 '21

For some people, any woman in any powerful position is a man hating feminazi.

21

u/Honoris_Causa Jul 21 '21

Utterly disgraceful

18

u/WhyCommentQueasy Jul 21 '21

Yeah, I missed those reviews.

All I can remember from when it came out is how thrilled everyone was that it wasn't just another soulless cash-grab sequel released decades after the originals.

35

u/KKlear Jul 21 '21

When it came out, the internet seemed to be full of idiots unironically saying that Immortan Joe did nothing wrong. It was equal parts unbelievable and disgusting.

10

u/RelevantEmu5 Jul 22 '21

Wasn't that film universally acclaimed and immediately labeled as an all time great.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

150

u/locksymania Jul 21 '21

It's a bloody great movie. Watched it over a couple of nights on Netflix when up feeding the youngest. Hardy gets plenty screen time. It's just he's not the only thing going on.

31

u/Darko33 Jul 22 '21

Furiosa was such a badass and complex character, played to perfection

12

u/RiotGrrr1 Jul 21 '21

Fury Road is one of my favorite movies of all time (and my husband's). His friend is a dumbass.

21

u/bambamkablam Jul 21 '21

His former friend is also an unemployed ultra conservative who is collecting unemployment but always screaming himself hoarse about socialism. We don’t miss him.

11

u/KKlear Jul 21 '21

and the idea of a female character who isn’t half naked and always on the brink of a swoon will prevent men from seeing a movie that they would likely enjoy.

Not to mention that the female characters in the movie aside from Furiosa are half-naked, so I guess the swoon part is what's really important.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21 edited Jul 21 '21

Watched this movie last night! I loved it!! Almost made me a bit emotional to see women being such badass “heroes”… really worth the watch. But did get the “oooo girl power” sarcastic comment from my bf while watching… also loved how there was no needless sexing up of the female characters I’ve come to expect in action movies with ladies in main roles

→ More replies

1k

u/DarkNFullOfSpoilers winning at brow game Jul 21 '21

Over on a certain movie related subreddit, they all hated The Old Guard for the same reason.

I'm gonna go support Gunpowder Milkshake now.

41

u/Must_Go_Faster_ Jul 21 '21

I came in here to mention “The old Guard” I didn’t think it was feminist because it had a female lead. The closest I would say I felt to that was how refreshing it was to not have a generic male lead. Can’t wait for the sequel!

→ More replies

873

u/ColorMeStunned Jul 21 '21

The Old Guard was SUCH a surprisingly good movie!

At a certain point, if you're gonna hate something simply because it features women, you're just missing out on a lot of good content.

70

u/BOPHoldItDown Jul 21 '21

I loveeee the old guard universe I especially want to see the backstory of Charlize Theron and her ex. The ex who was fricking tortured in the ocean for centuries, so much potential there to make not just a typical action movie

22

u/senseven Jul 21 '21

The "ex" is surely completely insane and she will be the 'villain' in the next movie. My nitpick for the unexpectedly good movie was the overly choreographed fighting scenes. Sometimes the actors just turned and acted way too early to rather "surprising" things, which took me out of scenes a little bit.

27

u/Nevyn522 Jul 21 '21

My naive take on it is that was just HOW experienced the Old Guard is. You get into enough fights, you can predict what's likely to happen. There were a few weapon tosses or handoffs that were the same way -- "I'll throw the gun over there and because we've done this a thousand times before you're going to be there to catch it." I didn't see it as poor choreography, although I can see that take.

→ More replies
→ More replies

204

u/Cloaked42m Jul 21 '21

Another movie that I'm looking forward to the sequel. The Old Guard is rewatchable too. Lots of fun things that go boom.

→ More replies

55

u/shitsandfarts Jul 21 '21

I LOVED the old guard. Was really disappointed in a lot of the dudes who told me it sucked.

→ More replies

71

u/Procris Jul 21 '21

No lie: the "rare book" in the first five minutes of Old Guard had Librarian Twitter in a storm, and the director actually responded and was like "My bad."

53

u/ivictoria Jul 21 '21

Say more things! What was about the book repellent to librarians??

83

u/Procris Jul 21 '21

In one of the opening scenes, the main character gifts another character a "First Edition" of Don Quixote. Don Quixote was first published in 1605. The book handed over is at best a late-19th century case bound, mass produced ... something. Definitely not a hand-press first edition of Quixote. There were lots of jokes about what "first" it represented. It was all in good fun.

37

u/FrankTank3 Jul 22 '21

I bonded with my husband on our first date showing him this First Edition Iliad. He’s a bit of a Classics nerd like me so it hit him pretty hard. I’m still surprised I could cause someone so much pain and yet still end up married to him. Maybe the writers of The Old Guard pulled this move as a little wink/nod to that Iliad bullshit.

→ More replies
→ More replies

107

u/Honigkuchenlives Jul 21 '21

Oh they hated it for the female characters, the POC and the gay characters.

34

u/onlyhere4laffs Jul 21 '21

I wish someone loved me like those two loved each other.

17

u/Honigkuchenlives Jul 21 '21

Ive watched that scene so many times Ive lost count. If Netflix doesn't do a prequel about those two they are even dumber than I thought.

8

u/onlyhere4laffs Jul 21 '21

I would watch that for daaaays :) I started watching it for "Charlize with a battle axe", I was NOT prepared for that love fest.

→ More replies

11

u/SilverDarner Jul 21 '21

They really sold PASSIONATELY IN LOVE, as opposed to just being horny for each other all the time. Adored them!

→ More replies

16

u/Gizwizard Jul 21 '21

That has by far been my favorite couple in any movie for a loooong time. Straight, gay, or otherwise. Just a lovely two souls who love each other.

→ More replies
→ More replies

87

u/IMJorose Jul 21 '21

On that note, I thought The Queen's Gambit was the best Netflix series of last year.

28

u/purplesquared Jul 21 '21

Hmm, I never checked it out because the acting seemed a bit meh in the trailer (but trailers often suck anyway) but hearing this I will definitely give it a try. The premise seemed really cool!

16

u/TheCrypticLegacy Jul 21 '21

I was the same I swear, seemed like a pretty average film from the trailer but the actual film is so much better than the trailer gives it credit.

→ More replies
→ More replies

204

u/taleo Jul 21 '21

What? Geez, how do they feel about older "feminist" movies like Aliens, or Terminator 2?

160

u/North-Tumbleweed-512 Jul 21 '21

The original Alien was written and then cast. So Ripley could have been played as man or woman and it works. As a result many of the key "woman" tropes aren't used.

→ More replies
→ More replies

133

u/undeadsasquatch Jul 21 '21

If you want a good laugh (or cry) go see what these people are saying about the new He-Man cartoon on Netflix... Lots of shitting on it for focusing a lot more on a female character.

And if you even know what He-Man is you really got to be at least in your thirties (40s if you grew up with it). So these are 30+ year old men complaining about a woman in a cartoon having a larger role...

21

u/Painting_Agency Jul 21 '21

I... I'm a child of the 80's and of all the things I never thought I'd read, "He-Man is too feminist now" might be up there on the list. (It looks decent though and I'm hoping my son gets into it)

53

u/guery64 Jul 21 '21

I have no idea who He-Man is, but She-Ra and the Princesses of Power is just great.

I would have thought people would like it more. I remember there was a community of people unironically loving My Little Pony - Friendship is Magic, and it kind of goes in a similar direction.

13

u/SpaceLemming Jul 21 '21

I’m not a huge he-man fan but have collected random bits. He-man and she-ra are siblings(twins?) in the old canon. They didn’t get into it in PoP but technically left open enough it could still be true. However I don’t believe the reboot uses PoP.

→ More replies
→ More replies

57

u/Lickerbomper Jul 21 '21

You mean the She-Ra reboot, or they rebooted He-Man also?

I know tons of men are complaining that new She-Ra doesn't have boobs and isn't sexualized. "OMG this show isn't written for me??? How dare they make a show for children appropriate for children????"

30

u/cynderisingryffindor Jul 21 '21

They (Kevin Smith) rebooted he-man.

On the topic of She-ra, She-ra is freaking awesome. My son (he was 18 months old at that time) was a wee lad when season 2 premiered and he loved it too (because colors). We visited universal and Disney world around that time (early December 2019), and while he couldn't care less about mickey and Donald, he lost his marbles when he saw the character actor for She-ra. Tbf, he also liked Olaf, Sven, and Elsa's horse, but he did show the greatest excitement for She-ra.

→ More replies

23

u/PimpNamedSlickback4 Jul 21 '21

The fucking Quartering. A grown man in his 30s complaining that a characters breasts weren't big enough. And that she wasn't sexy. I can't make this shit up. It's real. He made a whole video on it. It's so pathetic. And the character is a minor, right?

→ More replies

15

u/-Agonarch Jul 21 '21

I'm an old dude, and I really liked the new character design - it made a lot of sense to me.

The old one didn't make sense to me for someone raised as a soldier - surely they'd be comfortable in something similar to the uniform or armour they were used to.

Someone raised as a princess sure - the old one looks like a short, weaponized ballgown which she'd probably be comfortable in, but that's not what she was in either incarnation (I guess that's what the 'past' She-ra was in the new series though, so they retconned it which I think is good).

Plus new swiftwind is one of my favorite male characters certainly in masters of the universe but probably at all, he's got the traditionally female role of flamboyant appearance obsessed person (and they get away with it by making him a unicorn). Those men exist! They're not even uncommon! Why is this the first one I've seen that's not played as a gay trope?!

→ More replies
→ More replies

15

u/zerolight197 Jul 21 '21

Lol, "Old Guard" in particular was a movie my Dad recommended I watch. Turned out to be amazing movie!

110

u/mregg000 Jul 21 '21

Wait. What? The Old Guard was feminist? Did I miss something? Oh. Is it because they were led by a woman? I thought it was a fantastic, well written/directed/acted movie. Hoping for a sequel.

56

u/LicoriceSucks Jul 21 '21

It's not, but reeeee females taking all the good roles for men - who will need jobs!

/s

→ More replies

15

u/CerebusGortok Jul 21 '21

My friends and I are planning to play a tabletop RPG based on the Old Guard because we all enjoyed it so much. I didn't realize or think about the fact that the protagonist and other members of the team are women. It doesn't seem relevant to the story.

→ More replies

117

u/NFRNL13 Jul 21 '21

What I've heard about these situations from people I hung out with is that they find the idea of women doing these things to men to be unrealistic. "A highly trained man will always crush a highly trained woman because strength bla bla bla." "A woman is physically incapable of doing X,Y,Z so it's too weird when they do it in a movie"

My issue with these arguments as a fellow man is that it's just a movie, and I don't care. If the Rock is allowed to hold a helicopter with one arm in a FF movie, why isn't ScarJo allowed to assassinate people as an assassin? Sakura Haruno can crush boulders with her bare hands because it's fiction but no weebs seem to care about that.

19

u/AlissonHarlan Jul 22 '21

Then ask them if it's realistic when loli have boobs bigger than their head, a waist of 10 ''/22 cm and a huge bum. No they aren't bother by the fact that it's ''too weird'' now.

Because when it's ''conventionally attractive'' it's never an issue if it's realistic or weird. (i saw no men complain about jessica rabbit when it was released by example) because the woman don't treat their sense of masculinity(she's still here to amaze them) nor challenge their sense of what is attractive for them or not (imagine if they are attracted by a woman who have masculine characteristics...).

→ More replies
→ More replies

752

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21

But don't you find it annoying that there are so very few roles written for women? I grew up in the time of Xena the warrior princess and the yellow and pink power rangers, and my dad was a huge arrested development fan. I never doubted their parts for a second and it empowered the hell out of me. But if I now see movies that are just rewritten for women I can't escape the thought of it missing originality and style. We are not men, we are women, and there are so many stories about women that haven't been told yet. We need script writers to start writing original scripts for women, not rewrite male dominated scripts to piggyback on the feminist movement and earn some easy Hollywood money.

182

u/Overquoted Jul 21 '21

Man, I loved Xena. I still do. I've rewatched a bit in the last year and it kind of blows my mind that show existed in the 90s. She's still my high bar for female characters.

I love that Xena had quite a few lovers in her past without ever being slut-shamed for it. I loved, even more, that she was someone who had engaged in these awful and violent actions before turning away from them. She wasn't just naturally good. Even her actions "as the good guy" were considerably darker when contrasted to Gabrielle or even Hercules. Xena sometimes killed the bad guys; Gabrielle didn't. I think she was the first female character I ever saw who wasn't strictly a moral paragon. She's also the first female character I saw who had a child but wasn't in their child's life on a daily basis. She wasn't defined by it.

Xena wasn't perfect as a character or series (the male gaze was turned up to 11, oof), but she's a lot more complex as a character than say, the 'feminist achievement' that was the Wonder Woman movie, imo.

12

u/Haw_and_thornes Jul 22 '21

I agree with everything you said, I just want to tack on that the first Wonder Woman was fine, but what the hell was 1984? What a shit show that was.

→ More replies
→ More replies

180

u/lardyoxygenthief Jul 21 '21

Isn’t this the entire inspiration for Reese Witherspoon’s Hello Sunshine company? I loved this interview with Time that she did that echos all of your sentiments. Time Interview

87

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21

She is such an inspiration. I blame myself but I never figured her to be this articulated and erudite. She knows what she's talking about and I have a lot more confidence that the future of Hollywood will be more women-centric. Thanks for showing me this!

→ More replies
→ More replies

80

u/SeashoreMan Jul 21 '21

Over the weekend I watched This Changes Everything, and it was really eye opening to how few women are involved with movies/Hollywood. It's on US Netflix and worth a look!

→ More replies

46

u/Shanakitty Jul 21 '21

I feel the same. I want strong female characters, but by that I mean smart, capable, and well-written characters, who do something important for the plot beyond supporting a male lead, not necessarily physically strong, violent characters. I get that there's a market for that type of movie, so that's fine, but it feels like lazy writing to me, and not always very believable either, when you have a slim, conventionally attractive actress throwing around guys who are twice her weight like it's NBD (that's fine if she's supposed to have superpowers or something, of course).

→ More replies

81

u/RockitTopit Jul 21 '21

This is the reason many female protagonists in TV and Movies feel so two-dimensional.

The ones where the character is written properly / realistic are what we need more of. The contrived "girl-power" cliche scenes just feel forced; like the writers are checking a requirements box off the list.

→ More replies

94

u/sarahbae03 Jul 21 '21

I concure wholeheartedly. I appreciate woman taking a stand and telling the world we can be more than they expect us or even demand us to be but filling a woman into a man's role so literally feels a little disingenuous.

→ More replies
→ More replies

563

u/Rorcanna Jul 21 '21

Which is why we need more movies featuring women in otherwise male centered roles.

Nobody can tell me that John Wick is realistic with a male lead, but would be horribly unrealistic if a woman did the same shooting and surviving falling off fucking buildings...

It has to be normalized to a point where it isn't considered "feminist" to feature a badass woman in cookie cutter action. Men like to say that they have no problem with strong female leads, yet they keep contradicting themselves by tantruming whenever a woman fills a role in any movie featuring action and violence.

86

u/Mrs_WorkingMuggle Jul 21 '21

i honestly thought from the trailer that Gunpowder Milkshake was some sort of spinoff of John Wick. With the hotel thing, and the sort of secret underworld of hired assassins. Plus there was a pretty decent female assassin in John Wick so it made sense. (yes I know, she was a cheat and broke the rules, but I didn't view that as happening because her character was a woman, but just that there are shitty people.)

→ More replies

27

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21

I would watch the shit out of Jane Wick.

→ More replies

129

u/Forward__Momentum Jul 21 '21

This reminds me of a scene in Shadow and Bone where Jesper, the gunslinger in the band of plucky thieves and con men, seduces a stable boy as part of a heist.

I definitely had a moment where I was feeling "Whoa, this is weird, I'm being taken out of the experience by how out of place this scene feels." It took me a minute to realize that, if this weren't two men, this scene would be totally unremarkable. If it were a dashing male hero and the pretty receptionist, or the obligatory femme fatale and any man with a pulse, this scene would be unworthy of comment. Just a piece of fanservice that's a stock scene for a heist movie.

43

u/asuperbstarling Jul 21 '21

I didn't think it was out of place at all, but then again: bisexuality. My brain goes 'yes of course, they're so cute' and then only thinks about homophobic reactions to things I enjoyed after.

Also the Crows are absolutely the best part of the show by far.

→ More replies
→ More replies

148

u/blk_ink_111 Jul 21 '21

exactly this. i notice when theres a badass female lead, suddenly theres this wave of men who become film critics and say, « i have no problem with female leads, BUUUT they need to have ‘depth’ or blah blah blah». sure you can have this criticism, but i rarely see this argument used against male leads.

when its a male lead with no depth, its always “well its just a fun action film, it doesn’t need to be deep.” but a female lead needs to have a long and compeletely developed backstory, complex motivations, perfect amount of strengths and flaws, and is strong but not too strong (or else its not realistic i guess, but since when were all male leads realistic).

75

u/Lickerbomper Jul 21 '21

perfect amount of strengths and flaws, and is strong but not too strong

And thus, the coining of the Mary Sue term in media criticism. Basically, women began writing the same kind of bland, over-powered, power-fantasy characters that men have been writing for eons, except female, and suddenly we care about realistic, relateable characters.

At least, some people decided to coin Gary Stu to describe male characters of similar blandness and power-fantasy orientation.

Gary Stu just got a whole 4 hour borefest released from Zach Snyder, but guys eat it up.

→ More replies
→ More replies

87

u/Spank86 Jul 21 '21

On the other hand theres a lot of women in action films that are somewhat universally loved. From ripley in alien to trinity in the matrix.

I'd suggest its perhaps not women in action films alone they have an issue with. Its something more deep seated than that. Its what they percieve to be behind it.

Whether that perception is real or not, i suspect its a worry about conceding their space to another group.

21

u/OuchLOLcom Jul 21 '21

I think you're right. Its very similar to the pushback you get from conservatives about affirmative action. If there's even a hint that the casting or direction was at all influenced by politics or a desire to expand representation then its stupid and should be fought against.

→ More replies

61

u/Honigkuchenlives Jul 21 '21

If those movie had come out today the same weirdos would call them woke garbage.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

209

u/welliwasemily Jul 21 '21

I wonder if his stomach almost fell through his asshole when your boss said “what’s wrong with feminism?” I hope it did.

40

u/hot-gazpacho- Jul 22 '21

I would constantly call out one of my coworkers like this. He would profess that he was all for equal rights, but then he'd say stupid shit like "smaller girls can't drive big trucks."

Eventually he started whining about it. "Oh I knew you were just going to say something."

Fantastic. You're encroaching on self-awareness. Maybe stop saying stupid shit.

98

u/Vulgaris25 Jul 21 '21

Ah yes is the character a white, cis, hetero man or are they political?

→ More replies

768

u/Waury Jul 21 '21

In the first 15 minutes, the movie wasn’t “too feminist”. It was just “mostly about women”. Considering men feel overpowered when women are represented equally, must have been too much for his little heart.

104

u/TaibhseCait Jul 21 '21

I remember reading somewhere that (action?) cartoons with boy protagonists are default, as in will appeal to both boys and girls, whereas girl protagonist cartoons are usually marketed to girls only.

I think it was mentioned in an animation lecture? & How marketing/sales/head honchos shouldn't default like that because children are usually equally happy with both male or female protagonists, & its adults with the bigger biases...

42

u/Waury Jul 21 '21

Absolutely. Part of “boys will only like boy protagonists” is from parents (some of them don’t want to watch / love female characters as kids), and part is because… of the marketing. If they just did movies for kids, with boys and girls protagonists, it would eliminate the problem.

39

u/grubas Jul 21 '21

It's also networks. Nickelodeon didn't want Korra because they were worried about boys not watching.

So everybody is concerned...except the kids.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

72

u/Cloaked42m Jul 21 '21

the first 15 minutes is a gunfight in a diner and the protagonist trying to chase after her mother. cut to present day.

A synopsis would be "John Wick"-light. A kinder, gentler, John Wick movie. Still pretty brutal, but holds back at odd times.

21

u/Waury Jul 21 '21

It was a bit more “film noir” than John Wick though, or perhaps I’m not thinking of the right genre? But it had a level of exaggeration to it.

→ More replies
→ More replies

155

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21

Exactly, it wasn't that it was too much about women for him. It's that it wasn't enough about men.

158

u/Psychic_rock Jul 21 '21

“I can’t identify with anyone in this movie, there’s no strong male protagonist.”

“What do you think every non white man and every women felt for literally the entire history of movies?”

“That’s completely different”

or

“well now what? No more white men in movies? You’re being ridiculous”

A generalization of similar conversations I’ve had with more than one person.

77

u/gemInTheMundane Jul 21 '21

Honestly it's amazing. People who "couldn't identify with the characters" have no idea how much they're telling on themselves.

So, the experiences of people not of your race and gender are so jarringly unfamiliar that you can't identify with their common humanity? Okay dude, good to know. Never trusting you again.

→ More replies

117

u/PizzaAndWine99 Jul 21 '21

Literally having a slightly more diverse cast is considered “too political” for some people

→ More replies

10

u/grubas Jul 21 '21

It wasn't even about women, it was a B action movie mostly. Just featuring women characters.

40

u/Maalstrohm Jul 21 '21

Don't kid yourself: he didn't watch any of the movie and had no intention of doing so. His overly negative opinion and complete inability to back it up sounds exactly like the type of dweeb who gets their opinion from internet echo chambers and treats it as gospel without question.

→ More replies

66

u/Overquoted Jul 21 '21

Alien's Ripley wasn't written with a man or woman in mind, it was a role that could have been filled by either. Audiences didn't notice and she remains one of the most iconic horror characters to this day.

13

u/Gsteel11 Jul 22 '21

If it was done today the incels would bitch and moan. Cry about how unrealistic it is.

"Oh the men get caught but she somehow moves fast enough, what stupid writing!"

→ More replies

12

u/cicisbeette Jul 21 '21

One of my absolute favourite horror films of all time is still The Descent, which has an all-female cast.

→ More replies

57

u/Ozymander Jul 21 '21

I hate that shallow "argument"

Mention climate change? Too woke.

Have women playing typical male dominated roles? Too feminist

Non-binary character exists? Again, too woke.

Historically white character being played by a different skin color or gender? "This is culture war, y'all!"

→ More replies

175

u/WonderMew Jul 21 '21

If the women had been wearing tight vinyl, leather, or spent the movie with gratuitous boob, thigh, and ass shots, I'm sure it would have been fine by him (looking at you, Underworld, Resident Evil, and Fifth Element). If the women aren't undressed for the male gaze it's "too feminist" to that lot.

13

u/Throwaway7219017 Jul 21 '21

Nothing says feminism like a bowling jacket, lol.

I like movies with actors I enjoy. Hence, I like John Wick and I like Gunpowder Milkshake. I also like Old Guard and Atomic Blonde, just as I did Crank and The Transporter.

I’m a man, but other men that complain about movies like this are ridiculous.

→ More replies
→ More replies

252

u/36VWI Jul 21 '21

I was looking forward to seeing this. Also didnt make it very far. nothing based on gender, it just wasn't very good. Some 'fight scenes' looked like they were taken at day 1 of choreography walkthroughs then sped up in editing. I'll give it another go since you recommend it.

BTW Kill Bill is an actual good movie if you want to watch badass female leads in a gory action film.

203

u/ColorMeStunned Jul 21 '21

Also The Old Guard, Atomic Blonde (just ignore the plot), Terminator 2, Alien, Birds of Prey was decent, honestly Fast 9 had some awesome female action (no gore though), Mad Max Fury Road, Army of the Dead...

We're making progress, slowly, and mostly with the help of Our Lady of Action, Charlize Theron.

32

u/BeBa420 Jul 21 '21

Lol I liked army of the dead but honestly I think they told the wrong story. The opening credits with all the chaos in Las Vegas and how the city was sealed off? I wanna see that story

→ More replies

62

u/cedneko Jul 21 '21

OUR LADY OF ACTION is now her new official title in my household. Freaking great!

26

u/SexyLemurLibrarian Jul 21 '21

I liked The Descent. There were some pretty bad ass women there and the sequal actually lived up to the original!

18

u/Cloaked42m Jul 21 '21

The Descent and Descent 2 are definite MUST watch movies if you love horror.

They are almost, but not quite, on my 'too scary to watch again' list.

They are absolutely on my 'Don't go to sleep to this, cause you'll watch the whole damn thing' list.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

66

u/rickyakafish Jul 21 '21

You are missing Edge of Tomorrow too. Emily Blunt was the lead in that, i will take no questions.

13

u/Ahydell5966 Jul 21 '21

She's also great in "Sicario"

Also - Amy Adams in "Arrival"

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

87

u/SOL-Cantus Jul 21 '21

This is one of those weird, "it's really good AND really bad," things at the same time. It's fantastic that folks are making popcorn films where sex/gender isn't an object and a badass woman can kickass. It's terrible because we're continuing the trend of toxic masculinity that tends to be a throughline in them. If a scene has a woman forcing herself on the love interest (see god knows how many James Bond films and 80's/90's action flicks) because it's a cookie-cutter swap, the industry is still producing things that are objectively toxic even while removing one of the barriers to it.

And that's not even a significantly feminist take, that's a basic "sexual assault bad" take that we're somehow still grappling with as a society.

36

u/crackyzog Jul 21 '21

Oh, I really wanted to like this one. The women in this movie are so awesome and I'm always excited for this kind of movie.

The dialogue was so so so bad though. I thought maybe they tried to be so bad it was good but I don't know. I winced whenever Angela Bassett said anything. It certainly wasn't the fault of the people in the movie though. They did fine, I just think they took all of the old bad action films but cherry picked the worst line in each movie to use.

Also never a huge fan of the baby girl, baby doll thing in these movies. Maybe they were making fun of it but if they were it was still too cringey. I might have avoided that particular thing in general.

→ More replies
→ More replies

58

u/sadpandatown Jul 21 '21

Was watching with a male friend, and he mentioned how the lead (Karen Gillan) was 'so grumpy'. I just pointed out she had the exact same attitude as any Liam Neesan act, or Jason Statham.

I thought the movie was enjoyable, a good over the top action that doesn't take itself too seriously. What I'm not a fan of is how, and this seems to be a reoccurring theme in films that have an all-female main cast, all the 'bad guys' are male. Not a single woman they fought against. Women can be generic goons too!

→ More replies

78

u/zedeloc Jul 21 '21

Check out "Annihilation" for a great sci-fi thriller with an all female main cast. I suspect the only reason it didn't get better ratings is due to the all female leads.

25

u/Mac_and_dennis Jul 21 '21

One of my favorite movies ever. Read the books if you haven’t. Much bigger story with the books

→ More replies

26

u/alienclit Jul 21 '21

A lot of people say it’s bc of the hard to follow story and the main character isn’t sympathetic. Both are reasons I like it. I love an unsympathetic female lead. It’s more humanizing to me to depict someone who isn’t a Mary Sue.

→ More replies