r/OreGairuSNAFU • u/GrumpyRuno • 22d ago
No matter how ridiculous Shin is some characters are actually not Out of Character Light Novel - Serious
Firstly I want to talk about how Hachiman would've acted in Shin since he is DEFINITELY OOC and 1000x downgraded version of real one.
While Hachiman's past was always a comedic stuff and never talked seriously(because Watari is writing a fucking self insert) his life pretty much sucks and until Yukino there is not a single good stuff happening in there.
-Hated even before having bad eyes.
-Mom and dad always in job even when he was extremely young (How the fuck did he cook?? And how he cook only curry? Probably because that was only thing Watari could cook in that age?)
-Not just he was misfortune, also the people around him was also super bad and a unluck itself since not everyone is that suck but he kinda gains a supernatural observing ability from suffering.
-Stopped pitying himself long ago and suffering of past is a joke for him.
-Worst mother in the series is his mother and worst parent is his father... Looks like father is looking him like a nanny for Komachi and Mother kinda delude herself that she loves Hachiman even if that's a fucking lie since they act like he doesn't exist.
Now with all those hard stuff there is no way Hachiman letting ANY of those trio bothering Yukino, there is just no way, I don't believe he would bother or regret even if it's Komachi that he is destroying for Yukino.
So rather than this stupid stuff in shin, I would prefer if Yukino start to see what Hachiman is, she kinda failed to see how good he is at solving stuff and made a Pikachu face at election arc and was unsatisfied because she couldn't do anything so it would be interesting if she started to see those abilities of 'can outright save everyone' comes from 'infinite loses of past'
And btw Hachiman solves everything fucking perfectly not just half assed or something like others believe, Rumi could talk others and do stuff but in the end chose to stay away as we see in Christmas event, he succeeded. She is no longer forced to be a loner and rather choose to be, later Hachiman solves even that part of the problem by making her the star of event.
Confession arc, while no one could see he was the one realized Hina's request so he was solving 2 request that Yui and Yukino doesn't even realize... Did that perfectly and probably wouldn't need to self sacrifice if he knew that would bother the other two but did anyway because he wasn't aware.
The moment he become aware he fucking evolved and hence Yukino lost again.
A man like this cannot possibly endure those trio of thottery doing stuff that bothers yukino, she, at this point should be far more important than Komachi since it looks like they didn't even have a good sibling relationship before Hachiman started to come home early for her... There is a even a chance that Komachi wouldn't even bother to acknowledge him since parents doesn't and she is super spoiled.
Now I am explaining the title.
While Hachiman is OOC and story is bad... I do not think Yui, Komachi and Iroha is acting like Out of Character and turned into bitches, no, more like they always were.
Iroha's character was always poisonous and problematic, Hachiman never cared enough about her to fix it.
Komachi is super spoiled and her brothers like is pretty much is an entertainment most of the time, like she said "I come to mess- I mean come to help to my brother" she also can't understand Hachiman not always willing to talk about and have problems like she forced Hachiman to talk about what happend in confession arc without a tiniest patience expected from a family member nor privacy... Then literally turned into a fucking stranger the moment he showed a bit anger. She is worst than Haruno in my eyes(LoL)
Yui wants everything, she wants Yukino as Best friend and also own Hachiman. But she also wants to own Hachiman without having problem with her own clique and maybe having Hachiman in there without having any problem with Yumiko but while owning clique she also wants service club to stay until graduation.
Probably wants all of them to go same university.
When Yukino gave up everything in prom arc, she did nothing but took it... And since Hachiman is stunned because no Mather what he does about Yukino everyone will start scream co-dependency bullshit.
Basically these trio being such as they are in shin isn't something come out of nowhere, Yui was in the right way when she didn't give up like yukino but at this point it's a joke... She, Haruno and literally every character that didn't actually pointed or at least give a push to Yukino to realize Hachiman is pretty much salvation for both of them is just being a failure of friend/sister etc. Them being doing reverse is also very... Bad but unlike Haruno, Yui is smarter(yeah you won't be called smart after doing blunders since the start of the series onee-san) and even when she can fix everything without blunders she won't do since that would've make Yukino claim Hachiman instantly,with confidence.
Iroha, Yui, Komachi was all like this even before... Not so serious and definitely not minding manners or stuff like that.
That's all... Instead of every illogical stuff in Shin we might have Yukino heal Hachiman and actually help with his own family relations since it can't be compared to Yukinoshita's because it is literally non-existent, there is nothing to fixed since there was nothing broke. Literal zero... İf she learns that's enough though I rather see her family for Hachiman 'source of that and every type of love' since their friends and family doesn't and can't help the things caused in past... While Yukino kinda get closed with Haruno and can talk to her mother without being uncomfortable... If Hachiman magically fix his relationship with family that would be worse.
I like characters like Komachi and İroha when they aren't entering serious territory while failing miserably like Iroha wanting something genuine but not understanding a bit or Komachi setting the club again or commenting stuff about Hachiman's life like she is all knowing...Ahahahah.
No more stupid family plot or 3rd wheel... Give us more HachiYuki.
4
u/IrohaOrDeath 22d ago
I really tried to read it, but the wall of text was just a bit too much for me.