r/worldnews 15d ago

Western Australia has made it illegal to protest outside abortion clinics *Within 150 meters

https://www.sbs.com.au/news/western-australia-has-made-it-illegal-to-protest-outside-abortion-clinics
79k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

202

u/16yYPueES4LaZrbJLhPW 15d ago

There was a man, easily 80 years old, who would stand on the corner of a road right outside the city of the college I used to attend.

I saw him every time I drove past that corner. Every single day, at every time of the day, he was there. Equipped with a baby doll in a stroller and an 8ft sign, it was like this man was protesting for his life.

I felt bad for him. Especially since he was devoted to protesting a clinic that overall decreases the need for abortions, but provides them in a safe and sterile environment if necessary. I don't know if he realizes that these clinics will first compile all the resources they can to help you carry through with your pregnancy, and have stopped more abortions than he has.

176

u/PraiseGodJihyo 15d ago

They don't care. For them it's all about being righteous warriors for their god. All we can do is try to educate the young in the hopes that one day religion, at least fanatical religion, will be a relic of the past.

22

u/The-Lord-Moccasin 15d ago

I went to a private Christian school from K-12 and I can definitively say that's how these belief systems are propogated: Getting to kids before they can properly develop their mental skills and trapping them in such beliefs.

My analogy has always been: Imagine an athletics facility that claims "Send kids to our programs and we'll teach them how to exercise, run, leap, etc!" So parents drop their children off, the employees lead them inside, knock them out, and surgically remove their legs. Then the children crawl out when the program is finished, and the employees go home to sleep soundly knowing they've brought joy and goodness to this evil world. That's about what such schools are for academics rather than athletics.

I despise such fundamentalist worldviews with a passion only intimate knowledge could inflame, but I can't help but feel a deep pity for those I grew up with (and people like them) even as they spout nonsense and insanity and vitriol. They were born in a casket.

2

u/jasmine-blossom 15d ago

Do you think that there’s any way to teach someone critical thinking skills once they’ve been indoctrinated into that ideology?

2

u/Buscemi_D_Sanji 14d ago

Not op, but absolutely. It just takes time and exposure to new ideas and ways of thinking. So people who stay totally isolated within the religion are far far less likely to develop those skills than the kid who goes to a regular college and starts thinking for themselves

15

u/Cha-Le-Gai 15d ago

There's an old guy who walks up and down the shoulder of a major road near me, always dragging a 10-foot cross. Actually dragging isn't the right word. It has little caster wheels on the bottom. But still he'll do it for a few hours at a time in the Texas heat. I don't know what he protesting or promoting but all I can ever think is "this did is fucking crazy."

38

u/CalvinCopyright 15d ago

There is no religion without fanatical religion.

-12

u/FavorsForAButton 15d ago

There is no fanaticism without religion*

22

u/chronicwisdom 15d ago

People are never fanatical about their political/economic ideology or trivial things like sports. Nope, just religion.

1

u/KeeblerAndBits 15d ago

Right....I get what you're saying but if you're strictly looking at America, where tf do you think "fanatical" reoublicans come from if not fanatical religion?

2

u/grandoz039 15d ago

Do you think that main motivator for extreme Trump nutjobs is religion? For supremacy groups?

2

u/KnightTemplar777 15d ago

A positive no for that question. But really since your sentence is heavily biased I don’t know what specific nut jobs and groups you are referring to and their actions as a whole and not individually.

1

u/KnightTemplar777 15d ago

Really? You remember the “summer of love”? It was very one sided on the political spectrum.

16

u/JustABizzle 15d ago

Yes. Please educate Affectionate-Date-31 over there. They seem to be quite uneducated on this subject.

They might as well be the person shouting “baby killer!” to the women at the clinics.

Terminating an unwanted pregnancy is not killing a baby.

-40

u/Salty-Performer-8607 15d ago

Unwanted, I guess. If you call having a good time and getting pregnant. And getting abortion a good thing. Then there’s something wrong with society. Take responsibility for your actions.

39

u/JustABizzle 15d ago

Terminating an unwanted pregnancy is taking responsibility for your actions.

0

u/Salty-Performer-8607 14d ago

I guess, if you call a living baby in a women’s body. And killing it. Then calling it taking responsibility. Wow! You lazy people. Anything to make your life easier for yourself and not taking responsibility for your own actions.

2

u/JustABizzle 14d ago edited 14d ago

Listen, in most first world countries, when a woman becomes pregnant and she wasn’t planning on it, it kinda goes like this:

Doctor: Well, your vitals look good, you have no lumps in your breasts, your bloodwork and cholesterol levels all look great. This pregnancy should go well. Be sure to get your rest and avoid alcohol.

Woman: I’m pregnant?!

Doctor: Oh, well, yes. Were you not trying to get pregnant?

Woman: No, I wasn’t. I take birth control pills, but I forgot them when I went away for a weekend last month.

Doctor: Sometimes that’s all it takes. Are you in a long term relationship?

Woman: We’ve been together a few months, but I feel like we are still getting to know each other.

Doctor: Would you like to terminate this pregnancy? Or think about it? Maybe talk to your partner about carrying it to term?

Woman: Oh my god, no, I think it would freak him out. We only just decided to be exclusive. We certainly haven’t started talking about being parents together.

Doctor: So you’d like to terminate? We can take care of that right now, if you like.

Woman: Yes, definitely.

—————

Not sure why abortion is such a big deal in the US.

0

u/Salty-Performer-8607 14d ago

Because it’s a living being inside of a human body. Wow! So ignorant…

2

u/JustABizzle 14d ago

It really isn’t. It’s just a collection of cells that cannot survive without a host. Not quite a parasite, but close.

28

u/PlumpHughJazz 15d ago

People can take responsibility by terminating the pregnancy knowing they might not be capable parents in many ways. Could be they don't have money to raise the baby or living under their own roof.

Safe sex and birth control can still fail. Don't try to imply having sex will always result in getting the woman pregnant.

23

u/JustABizzle 15d ago

Not wanting to be a mother is enough reason to get an abortion, if an unplanned pregnancy occurs.

-2

u/time2trouble 15d ago

I would support that as long as an equivalent "not wanting to be a father" option is also provided.

3

u/Tyr808 15d ago

That's really not the topic bring discussed at the moment, but yeah I don't think men should be totally at the mercy of the woman's wishes in the event birth control fails.

There should be a reasonable framework for a man not wishing to be a parent to opt out. There should NOT however be any level of control on the abortion itself. The man should be protected from being a parent against his will and wishes, but that's where it stops. A man who wants the pregnancy to continue doesn't get any say over the abortion because that all goes on in the woman's body.

3

u/time2trouble 15d ago

Definitely. The choice for the man should be whether to be a father, not whether the birth takes place.

13

u/dreedweird 15d ago

And there it is. The slut shaming. Yep, dem wimmins must be punished for having sex, innit?

How about punishing their partners? No? Or hey, how about non-consensual sex? Surely, women must be punished for that, as well. Oh, riiight, they are: no abortion for them, either, amirite?

1

u/time2trouble 15d ago

Yep, dem wimmins must be punished for having sex

Strangely, in my experience, anti-abortion protesters are about 80% women and 20% men.

3

u/LadyOurania 15d ago

The idea that sexism and the patriarchy is exclusively enforced by men is so false. Just as plenty of men will jump to calling another man a pussy for showing emotion, plenty of women will jump to calling another woman a whore for not being celibate. Sexism is a system that is forced on everyone, and enforced by conservatives of all kinds.

3

u/The-Lord-Moccasin 15d ago edited 15d ago

I was raised to believe this (not any longer, though) and was talking to a friend about it once, how - whether it's true or not - at least some people genuinely believe it's a matter of protecting life. She made a good point that, if so, they should also be equally zealous in promoting proper sex education, safe sex methods, even free contraceptives, to make it a nonissue; yet the majority are equally opposed to such instead.

I can appreciate that there is potentially genuine concern for life involved, but setting aside that medical professionals (who are certainly better qualified to answer) disagree over the matter of when a fetus qualifies as life, the belief systems that oppose abortion tend to hold contradictory beliefs and behaviors regarding concern for others' wellfare.

How many people have I known who, on the basis of a soul, believe ending a life before it's begun is wrong, yet also see no issue with the predestined damnation of a soul before it's even conceived? Most of them, it happens. The same illogic is necessary for both.

5

u/CX316 15d ago

Considering how many of those people think contraception (be it the pill, or plan-b or whatever else) counts as an abortion, and that they think that safe sex education promotes promiscuity, they're really just fucking themselves (which I think they're also against)

-13

u/Somberiety 15d ago

Terminating an unwanted pregnancy is not killing a baby.

Whatever helps you sleep at night, but we both know deep down inside you don't believe that.

2

u/JustABizzle 14d ago

lol. Tell me more about what I believe.

-1

u/KnightTemplar777 15d ago

*indoctrinate

8

u/wretch5150 15d ago

In downtown Denver in the late 1990s/early 2000s there was an Abraham Lincoln cosplay weirdo on the 16th Street Mall that would be constantly loudmouthing against abortion as if it were his job.

7

u/FapplePie85 15d ago

These people jerk off to the Constitution then conveniently forget that abortion is constitutionally-protected. Abe would probably be fine with abortion.

2

u/gelinrefira 15d ago

I blame the people who indoctrinated him to become an asshole.

1

u/seductivestain 15d ago

Lol he doesn't give a fuck about the well being of anyone. He just wants young people to suffer consequences for enjoying premarital sex.

1

u/Grizzly_Berry 15d ago

8 feet tall or wide?