So a view I see a lot nowadays is that attention spans are getting shorter, especially when it comes to younger generations. And the growing success of short form content on Tiktok, Youtube and Twitter for example seems to support this claim. I have a friend in their early 20s who regularly checks their phone (sometimes scrolling Tiktok content) as we’re watching a film. And an older colleague recently was pleased to see me reading a book, because he felt that anyone my age and younger was less likely to want to invest the time in reading.

But is this actually true on the whole? Does social media like Tiktok really mould our interests and alter our attention? In some respects I can see how it could change our expectations. If we’ve come to expect a webpage to load in seconds, it can be frustrating when we have to wait minutes. But to someone that was raised with dial-up, perhaps that wouldn’t be as much of an issue. In the same way, if a piece of media doesn’t capture someone in the first few minutes they may be more inclined to lose focus because they’re so used to quick dopamine hits from short form content. Alternatively, maybe this whole argument is just a ‘kids these days’ fallacy. Obviously there are plenty of young adults that buck this trend.

  • Guenther_Amanita@feddit.de
    2·
    1 year ago

    Nothing has changed

    I don’t believe anything has changed neurologically or psychologally in the last decades.

    There have always been people who are more susceptible to consume “trashy” (provoking, easy to consume) media.

    Once it was low-quality newspapers (a german band once refered to them as “fear, hate, tits and the weather forecast”, which fits really well!), then it was trash TV, then mobile games, and now TikTok and stuff. Some people are just attracted to flashy stuff and can’t get enough dopamine.

    It’s just that the latter example is very new, and everything new is automatically bad, no matter what.

    There have always been young people who read books, create art, video game, listen or create music, have hobbies, and so on.

    BUT, something has changed:

    One word: attention economy. Capitalism realized, that especially in combination with ads, you can create A LOT of money by making easy to consume content.

    If a platform uses dark patterns (emotional or funny content, reinforcement, short content instead of longer stuff, flashy stuff, likes, endless scrolling, keeping you as long as possible in the app, etc.), it makes a lot more money with it’s users.

    Years of algorithms perfectionized manipulating you and your attention span with supernatural stimuli (as mentioned above).

    What to do with those informations?

    Notice, how boring Lemmy, RSS-feeds, and stuff like that are?

    After checking my posts for this day, I’m done and do something different, like cleaning the kitchen. Now, I’m on the toilet and don’t have anything else to do, and I have fun answering you :)

    That’s how our devices should work. I don’t wanna be a slave, I want to own my device, and not the other way around.

    Tbh, I’m grateful Reddit went downhill. A year ago I could never imagine nuking my account.

    I spent my whole teenage and now adult years (15 - now) on that shithole, was super addicted and couldn’t spend 2 minutes without checking my phone, even in meetings, dates, and so on. It was just as bad as vaping for me. I knew, that it was slowly killing every brain cell, but “loved” it too much.

    Thanks, u/spez ❤️ You killed Reddit for me and made my new “Reddit” (-> Lemmy, but with the same app) THAT boring for me I bought an e-reader now to read books instead😂

    • OmegaMouse@feddit.ukOPEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      Yes I think you’re right. People haven’t changed, but the environment has changed - it’s continually getting better at manipulating us.

      Lemmy does have a limited amount of content, but what it does have seems to be of higher quality. Which is perfect! We don’t need constant, cheap content.

  • iByteABit [he/him]@lemm.ee
    1·
    1 year ago

    Try reading a book for 5 hours in the city surrounded by your devices, and try doing it in nature with no devices around you. We didn’t change, but our world did and we adapt with it. Of course, things wouldn’t be so bad if there weren’t people getting unimaginably rich by trapping your attention.

  • Night Monkey@sh.itjust.works
    0·
    1 year ago

    I can’t stand tiktok, Instagram or any of those short video sites.

    I still watch hour long YouTube videos of dudes working on cars and documentaries talking about the most random things you can imagine.

    People are getting dumber and their attention span sucks

    • Cort@lemmy.world
      1·
      1 year ago

      Every 30 days I have to hide YouTube shorts because if I don’t I’ll get sucked into a hole until 3 in the morning without even realizing it.

      I still watch long form content, but man are those shorts addictive.