What I can’t stand is the chaotic stupid choices being your only option for evil. Offer an evil route but make it more interesting than playing a character with poor impulse control and access to infinite puppies.
If you’ve never tried it, the Wasteland series does evil very well. The game lets you go murder hobo, but that’s not the actual evil route. The evil route is very interesting, and while the options are morally grey there’s a clear good and bad choice
What I can’t stand is the chaotic stupid choices being your only option for evil. Offer an evil route but make it more interesting than playing a character with poor impulse control and access to infinite puppies.
Cough cough Baldur’s Gate 3… You either agree to help or aggro everyone.
If you’ve never tried it, the Wasteland series does evil very well. The game lets you go murder hobo, but that’s not the actual evil route. The evil route is very interesting, and while the options are morally grey there’s a clear good and bad choice