Maybe my favourite short story ever. Def top 5. The story on which the incredible Dennis Vellenuve movie Arrival is based. Which is also my favorite movie. Basically I couldnt recommend this story enough!

  • Donjuanme@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    8 months ago

    One should never expect much from movies based on books, but let’s not write off a movie because of it’s lead, Jim Carrey did eternal Sunshine of the spotless mind, and did it pretty well despite that definitely not being his style going into it.

    Independence Day is a different take on the alien invasion, it’s nowhere near as philosophical or nuanced as arrival, but imo it’s another valid take about how it would be going down. There’s a “throwaway” line that got cut that really hurts the plot, but I’m not sure how to convey it without risking spoilers (something I’m highly adverse to)

    Top 3 movies of mine would have to be: ‘the usual suspects’, ‘love actually’ and … Hmmm, ‘my cousin Vinny’ a very 90s set of movies, but I’m a child of that era.

    Short stories are going to be ‘the last question’ ‘the story of your life’, and ‘i don’t know Timmy, being God is a big responsibility’ (although the boy who predicted earthquakes hotly contends spot 3). All 3 are easily consumed in a short break, and provoke substantial thought.

    • Lacanoodle@literature.cafeOPM
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      8 months ago

      Oh no I seemed to have misphrased my original statememt. I font think the lead changes much barring the potential to get funded and marketing. And I do like Gosling. The reason I dont ecpect much is bc it appears to be a cash grab more than a project on it’s own.

      Tho I will say I also loved External Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and The Truman Show and never liked any Jim Carrey movie.

      I do like your choice of short stories, though I haven’t read ‘I don’t know timmy …’. Really think you would lobe Borges. You ought to search borges in this community and you’ll find some of his stories I’ve posted.

      That’s funny, I was just talking about how the Usual Suspects has aged yesterday with a friend. That really is a very era specific taste!